July 08, 2004

TestNG precisions

Robert (sorry, couldn't figure out his name) wrote a few interesting criticisms about TestNG:

JUnit's got huge traction in the Java community because of the tool support.

I disagree.  I think JUnit got traction because there was nothing else when it came out.  It was simple, lightweight, easy to use, so everybody adopted it.  Fair enough.  Then its limitations started showing and since its development was pretty much stopped then, people started building tools to work around its limitations.

And here is where I think the problem is with JUnit:  the JUnit tools fix deficiciencies in its design.  For example, the ant task allows you to launch the runner on a wildcard of classes or suites, which you can't do with JUnit.  A lot of the value added by these tools should have been retrofitted in JUnit by now.  But they haven't, because JUnit is basically a dead project by now.

If the only way you can easily launch tests remains from the command-line, it's not going to work very well.

I am not so sure about that either.  Running tests from your IDE is definitely a plus (and I plan on writing an Eclipse plug-in once Eclipse understands JSR 175 annotations), but I believe that most of unit testing happens in automated builds.  A good testing framework needs to be extremely flexible from the command line, that's a requirement.  Which, as I said above and in previous postings, JUnit fails to achieve in many ways.

Case in point: how can I easily launch, in TestNG, both my older JUnit tests and the new-fangled ones?

It's pretty easy to do, but you will need to run the launcher twice.  This is just because I made the "JUnit compatibility flag" per-suite instead of per-test.  It seems to make more sense this way, but this is pretty easy to modify.

I hate the way the only log format for TestNG is a HTML file.

I agree.  This was just a proof of concept to get you started.  Right out of the box, TestNG gives you an easy-to-read HTML page that the most novice user can read and understand.  But TestNG is fairly extensible and easy to modify.  Since it's such an early stage, I haven't had the time to polish that part yet, but there is an important part of TestNG that you might have overlooked:  it gives you an API to inspect its running process.

For example, you can add listeners that will keep you informed when a test starts, when it ends, if it succeeded, if it failed, why, etc...  As you can see, adding your own logger and report generator is straightforward.  In comparison, JUnit is a big black box.

There's not a single Decorator in sight in TestNG.

Let's take this offline, I'm not quite sure what you are asking for here.

Not to be nitpicky, but... I absolutely loathe the use of the 'I' to mark an interface. Can't stand it. Makes me shudder and have flashbacks to when I used to write Microsoft COM code in C.

Ah, well, sorry about that.  It's a widely-used standard, though (Microsoft, Eclipse and WebLogic Workshop use it, and they certainly know their stuff...).  You'll get used to it :-)

At any rate, thanks for the feedback.  Contrary to what a lot of people think, I didn't write TestNG to kill JUnit but to make people think.  So many toolkits and frameworks are considered for granted these days that nobody even thinks of improving them any more (e.g JUnit, Velocity or XDoclet to name a few).  If TestNG causes JUnit to be improved, I'm all for it!

That being said, I have had a few more ideas to improve TestNG recently, which will show how powerful annotations can be compared to the "old way".  Stay tuned, I'll blog about this very soon.

Robert, feel free to email me so we can continue the discussion!

Posted by cedric at July 8, 2004 09:01 AM

http://www.fozzyr.kokoom.com/index.html lower cholesterol
http://www.fozzyr.kokoom.com/cholesterol-diet-lower.html lower cholesterol diet
lower cholesterol
lower cholesterol diet
[url=http://www.fozzyr.kokoom.com/index.html ]lower cholesterol[/url]
[url=http://www.fozzyr.kokoom.com/cholesterol-diet-lower.html ]lower cholesterol diet[/url]

Posted by: Jora Ngun at January 3, 2007 06:38 AM

http://www.ocf.berkeley.edu/~lasa/imagegallery/image/view.php?gid=16&phid=11258 carisoprodol
[link=http://www.ocf.berkeley.edu/~lasa/imagegallery/image/view.php?gid=16&phid=11258 ]carisoprodol[/link]
[url=http://www.ocf.berkeley.edu/~lasa/imagegallery/image/view.php?gid=16&phid=11258 ]carisoprodol[/url].

Posted by: carisoprodol at January 4, 2007 05:54 AM

http://www.ocf.berkeley.edu/~lasa/imagegallery/image/view.php?gid=16&phid=11258 carisoprodol
[link=http://www.ocf.berkeley.edu/~lasa/imagegallery/image/view.php?gid=16&phid=11258 ]carisoprodol[/link]
[url=http://www.ocf.berkeley.edu/~lasa/imagegallery/image/view.php?gid=16&phid=11258 ]carisoprodol[/url].

Posted by: carisoprodol at January 4, 2007 05:55 AM

venetian blinds.
http://venetian1blinds.blogspot.com venetian blinds
[link=http://venetian1blinds.blogspot.com ]venetian blinds[/link]
[url=http://venetian1blinds.blogspot.com ]venetian blinds[/url].

Posted by: venetian blinds at January 9, 2007 04:00 PM

http://affiliate-marketing-referral.dracu.info affiliate marketing referral affiliate marketing referral [url=http://affiliate-marketing-referral.dracu.info ]affiliate marketing referral[/url]
http://acne-blemish-laser-treatment.dracu.info acne blemish laser treatment acne blemish laser treatment [url=http://acne-blemish-laser-treatment.dracu.info ]acne blemish laser treatment[/url]
http://1st-franklin-financial.dracu.info 1st franklin financial 1st franklin financial [url=http://1st-franklin-financial.dracu.info ]1st franklin financial[/url]
http://mortgage-rates.mpprn.info mortgage rates mortgage rates [url=http://mortgage-rates.mpprn.info ]mortgage rates[/url]
http://mortgage-rate.mpprn.info mortgage rate mortgage rate [url=http://mortgage-rate.mpprn.info ]mortgage rate[/url]

Posted by: JOON at January 17, 2007 01:44 AM

http://villa-holidays-in-france.dracu.info villa holidays in france villa holidays in france [url=http://villa-holidays-in-france.dracu.info ]villa holidays in france[/url]
http://top-photography-schools.dracu.info top photography schools top photography schools [url=http://top-photography-schools.dracu.info ]top photography schools[/url]
http://search-engine-marketing-scotland.mpprn.info search engine marketing scotland search engine marketing scotland [url=http://search-engine-marketing-scotland.mpprn.info ]search engine marketing scotland[/url]
http://orlando-vacation-resort.dracu.info orlando vacation resort orlando vacation resort [url=http://orlando-vacation-resort.dracu.info ]orlando vacation resort[/url]
http://organizing-kids-rooms.mpprn.info organizing kids rooms organizing kids rooms [url=http://organizing-kids-rooms.mpprn.info ]organizing kids rooms[/url]

Posted by: JOON at January 17, 2007 04:16 PM

http://fitness-calendar.duftigst.info fitness calendar fitness calendar [url=http://fitness-calendar.duftigst.info ]fitness calendar[/url]
http://free-black-gay-personals.horenen.info free black gay personals free black gay personals [url=http://free-black-gay-personals.horenen.info ]free black gay personals[/url]
http://iranian-dating.horenen.info iranian dating iranian dating [url=http://iranian-dating.horenen.info ]iranian dating[/url]
http://lds-singles-online.duftigst.info lds singles online lds singles online [url=http://lds-singles-online.duftigst.info ]lds singles online[/url]
http://microsoft-anti-spam-software.horenen.info microsoft anti spam software microsoft anti spam software [url=http://microsoft-anti-spam-software.horenen.info ]microsoft anti spam software[/url]

Posted by: JOON at January 18, 2007 04:54 PM

http://new-hotmail-email.horenen.info new hotmail email new hotmail email [url=http://new-hotmail-email.horenen.info ]new hotmail email[/url]
http://power-of-attorney-revocation.duftigst.info power of attorney revocation power of attorney revocation [url=http://power-of-attorney-revocation.duftigst.info ]power of attorney revocation[/url]
http://rack-wine-wire.horenen.info rack wine wire rack wine wire [url=http://rack-wine-wire.horenen.info ]rack wine wire[/url]
http://resume-writing-business.duftigst.info resume writing business resume writing business [url=http://resume-writing-business.duftigst.info ]resume writing business[/url]
http://scotts-lawn-mower.horenen.info scotts lawn mower scotts lawn mower [url=http://scotts-lawn-mower.horenen.info ]scotts lawn mower[/url]

Posted by: hoor at January 19, 2007 07:52 AM

http://stock-photography-company.horenen.info stock photography company stock photography company [url=http://stock-photography-company.horenen.info ]stock photography company[/url]
http://susan-komen-breast-cancer-foundation.horenen.info susan komen breast cancer foundation susan komen breast cancer foundation [url=http://susan-komen-breast-cancer-foundation.horenen.info ]susan komen breast cancer foundation[/url]
http://teen-pregnancy-abortion.duftigst.info teen pregnancy abortion teen pregnancy abortion [url=http://teen-pregnancy-abortion.duftigst.info ]teen pregnancy abortion[/url]
http://turbo-tax-form.horenen.info turbo tax form turbo tax form [url=http://turbo-tax-form.horenen.info ]turbo tax form[/url]
http://turbo-tax-forms.horenen.info turbo tax forms turbo tax forms [url=http://turbo-tax-forms.horenen.info ]turbo tax forms[/url]

Posted by: hoop at January 20, 2007 04:38 AM

http://sbc-yahoo-dsl-email.qufbvl.info sbc yahoo dsl email sbc yahoo dsl email [url=http://sbc-yahoo-dsl-email.qufbvl.info ]sbc yahoo dsl email[/url] http://san-diego-tv-guide.soignio.info san diego tv guide san diego tv guide [url=http://san-diego-tv-guide.soignio.info ]san diego tv guide[/url] http://retirement-options.copestic.info retirement options retirement options [url=http://retirement-options.copestic.info ]retirement options[/url] http://creative-writing-scholarships.qufbvl.info creative writing scholarships creative writing scholarships [url=http://creative-writing-scholarships.qufbvl.info ]creative writing scholarships[/url] http://christian-dating-single-site-web.copestic.info christian dating single site web christian dating single site web [url=http://christian-dating-single-site-web.copestic.info ]christian dating single site web[/url]

Posted by: loh at January 23, 2007 03:19 AM

Passo in rassegna e sega voi Web site e lo ho trovato molto interessante. Grazie per il buon lavoro, greeting

Posted by: Jozephine at January 25, 2007 01:17 PM

http://senior-financial-planning.lysog.info senior financial planning senior financial planning [url=http://senior-financial-planning.lysog.info ]senior financial planning[/url] http://fitness-management.malig.info fitness management fitness management [url=http://fitness-management.malig.info ]fitness management[/url] http://email-address-uk.malig.info email address uk email address uk [url=http://email-address-uk.malig.info ]email address uk[/url] http://disney-world-florida-vacation.lysog.info disney world florida vacation disney world florida vacation [url=http://disney-world-florida-vacation.lysog.info ]disney world florida vacation[/url] http://what-is-bad-debt.lysog.info what is bad debt what is bad debt [url=http://what-is-bad-debt.lysog.info ]what is bad debt[/url]

Posted by: zero at January 26, 2007 12:25 PM

http://equipment-fitness-paramount.lysog.info equipment fitness paramount equipment fitness paramount [url=http://equipment-fitness-paramount.lysog.info ]equipment fitness paramount[/url] http://employment-yahoo.lysog.info employment yahoo employment yahoo [url=http://employment-yahoo.lysog.info ]employment yahoo[/url] http://e-commerce-news.malig.info e commerce news e commerce news [url=http://e-commerce-news.malig.info ]e commerce news[/url] http://divorce-lawyer-nyc.lysog.info divorce lawyer nyc divorce lawyer nyc [url=http://divorce-lawyer-nyc.lysog.info ]divorce lawyer nyc[/url] http://diabetes-type-1-2.lysog.info diabetes type 1 2 diabetes type 1 2 [url=http://diabetes-type-1-2.lysog.info ]diabetes type 1 2[/url]

Posted by: tupoi at January 29, 2007 06:07 AM

http://creative-writing-software.lysog.info creative writing software creative writing software [url=http://creative-writing-software.lysog.info ]creative writing software[/url] http://computer-recovery-software.lysog.info computer recovery software computer recovery software [url=http://computer-recovery-software.lysog.info ]computer recovery software[/url] http://computer-networking-san-antonio.malig.info computer networking san antonio computer networking san antonio [url=http://computer-networking-san-antonio.malig.info ]computer networking san antonio[/url] http://computer-management-project-software.malig.info computer management project software computer management project software [url=http://computer-management-project-software.malig.info ]computer management project software[/url] http://closet-remodeling.lysog.info closet remodeling closet remodeling [url=http://closet-remodeling.lysog.info ]closet remodeling[/url]

Posted by: qwer at January 29, 2007 03:58 PM

http://what-is-manic-depression.tonsb.info what is manic depression what is manic depression [url=http://what-is-manic-depression.tonsb.info ]what is manic depression[/url] http://wisconsin-tax-return.herifi.info wisconsin tax return wisconsin tax return [url=http://wisconsin-tax-return.herifi.info ]wisconsin tax return[/url] http://what-is-mortgage-insurance.tonsb.info what is mortgage insurance what is mortgage insurance [url=http://what-is-mortgage-insurance.tonsb.info ]what is mortgage insurance[/url] http://what-is-no-fault-divorce.sentici.info what is no fault divorce what is no fault divorce [url=http://what-is-no-fault-divorce.sentici.info ]what is no fault divorce[/url] http://what-is-options-trading.tonsb.info what is options trading what is options trading [url=http://what-is-options-trading.tonsb.info ]what is options trading[/url]

Posted by: kool at February 2, 2007 04:18 PM

The Black dating site for African American singles. Enjoy chat, instant messaging, message boards, personals, and more. Sign up where black people meet everyday. We Bring Black Singles Together!
black planet black black girl black woman black man black singles African American personals black chat black dating black people meet

Posted by: African American personals at February 7, 2007 08:36 PM

HELP. Who than can on treatment 6 years children. It is necessary 75 000 $ dollars for complex operation. We ask you. Though as that help. Forward means for electronic purse WEBMONEY: WMID - 244643338994, Purse - Z379794871935. Parents of the boy.

Posted by: detcoil at February 11, 2007 04:28 AM

http://data-management.seosunt1k.info data management data management [url=http://data-management.seosunt1k.info ]data management[/url]
http://brooklyn-college.seosunt1k.info brooklyn ollege brooklyn ollege [url=http://brooklyn-college.seosunt1k.info ]brooklyn ollege[/url]
http://blepharoplasty.seosunt1k.info blepharoplasty blepharoplasty [url=http://blepharoplasty.seosunt1k.info ]blepharoplasty[/url]
http://bus-travel.seosunt1k.info bus travel bus travel [url=http://bus-travel.seosunt1k.info ]bus travel[/url]
http://criminal-defense-lawyer.seosunt1k.info criminal defense lawyer criminal defense lawyer [url=http://criminal-defense-lawyer.seosunt1k.info ]criminal defense lawyer[/url]
http://reference-software.seosunt1k.info reference software reference software [url=http://reference-software.seosunt1k.info ]reference software[/url]

Posted by: joon at February 16, 2007 07:16 AM

http://kidney-failure.ignobbe.info kidney failure kidney failure [url=http://kidney-failure.ignobbe.info ]kidney failure[/url] http://all-inclusive-vacation-package.atores.info all inclusive vacation package all inclusive vacation package [url=http://all-inclusive-vacation-package.atores.info ]all inclusive vacation package[/url] http://excelsior-college.atores.info excelsior college excelsior college [url=http://excelsior-college.atores.info ]excelsior college[/url] http://deck-design.ignobbe.info deck design deck design [url=http://deck-design.ignobbe.info ]deck design[/url] http://wireless-headphones.ignobbe.info wireless headphones wireless headphones [url=http://wireless-headphones.ignobbe.info ]wireless headphones[/url]

Posted by: qwer at February 18, 2007 04:22 AM

http://chase-home-finance.soignio.info chase home finance chase home finance [url=http://chase-home-finance.soignio.info ]chase home finance[/url]
http://nursing-journals.copestic.info nursing journals nursing journals [url=http://nursing-journals.copestic.info ]nursing journals[/url]
http://bunn-coffee-maker.herspara.info bunn coffee maker bunn coffee maker [url=http://bunn-coffee-maker.herspara.info ]bunn coffee maker[/url]
http://pet-sitting.herspara.info pet sitting pet sitting [url=http://pet-sitting.herspara.info ]pet sitting[/url]
http://breast-cancer-symptom.restenli.info breast cancer symptom breast cancer symptom [url=http://breast-cancer-symptom.restenli.info ]breast cancer symptom[/url]

Posted by: Mdiaaga at February 18, 2007 07:58 AM

http://weight-loss-journal.copestic.info weight loss journal weight loss journal [url=http://weight-loss-journal.copestic.info ]weight loss journal[/url]
http://credit-repair-uk.herspara.info credit repair uk credit repair uk [url=http://credit-repair-uk.herspara.info ]credit repair uk[/url]
http://finance-car-rim.herspara.info finance car rim finance car rim [url=http://finance-car-rim.herspara.info ]finance car rim[/url]
http://tv-shelf.herspara.info tv shelf tv shelf [url=http://tv-shelf.herspara.info ]tv shelf[/url]
http://ben-hogan-golf-club.soignio.info ben hogan golf club ben hogan golf club [url=http://ben-hogan-golf-club.soignio.info ]ben hogan golf club[/url]

Posted by: trew at February 18, 2007 05:31 PM

http://acid-reflux-diet.monyar.info acid reflux diet [url=http://acid-reflux-diet.monyar.info]acid reflux diet[/url]
http://stomach-virus.oliacili.info stomach virus [url=http://stomach-virus.oliacili.info]stomach virus[/url]
http://income-tax-software.oliacili.info income tax software [url=http://income-tax-software.oliacili.info]income tax software[/url]
http://tax-office.otered.info tax office [url=http://tax-office.otered.info]tax office[/url]
http://nutrition-product.mirect.info nutrition product [url=http://nutrition-product.mirect.info]nutrition product[/url]

Posted by: Djjjk at February 19, 2007 06:42 AM

http://mexico-real-estate.malig.info mexico real estate [url=http://mexico-real-estate.malig.info]mexico real estate[/url]
http://estate-mexico-new-real.lysog.info estate mexico new real [url=http://estate-mexico-new-real.lysog.info]estate mexico new real[/url]
http://forex-trader.lysog.info forex trader [url=http://forex-trader.lysog.info]forex trader[/url]
http://insight-communication.malig.info insight communication [url=http://insight-communication.malig.info]insight communication[/url]
http://wine-gift-basket.malig.info wine gift basket [url=http://wine-gift-basket.malig.info]wine gift basket[/url]

Posted by: Maria at February 20, 2007 03:02 PM

http://work-ethic-test.knaphy.info work ethic test work ethic test [url=http://work-ethic-test.knaphy.info ]work ethic test[/url]
http://zoloft-and-depression.knaphy.info zoloft and depression zoloft and depression [url=http://zoloft-and-depression.knaphy.info ]zoloft and depression[/url]
http://zenith-television.knaphy.info zenith television zenith television [url=http://zenith-television.knaphy.info ]zenith television[/url]
http://yield-investment-calculator.knaphy.info yield investment calculator yield investment calculator [url=http://yield-investment-calculator.knaphy.info ]yield investment calculator[/url]
http://yankee-magazine.knaphy.info yankee magazine[/url] yankee magazine[/url] [url=http://yankee-magazine.knaphy.info ]yankee magazine[/url]

Posted by: folo at February 21, 2007 07:21 AM

http://yamaha-motorcycle-accessories.knaphy.info yamaha motorcycle accessories yamaha motorcycle accessories [url=http://yamaha-motorcycle-accessories.knaphy.info ]yamaha motorcycle accessories[/url]
http://yahoo-front-page.knaphy.info yahoo front page yahoo front page [url=http://yahoo-front-page.knaphy.info ]yahoo front page[/url]
http://writing-research-paper.knaphy.info writing research paper writing research paper [url=http://writing-research-paper.knaphy.info ]writing research paper[/url]
http://writing-persuasive-essay.knaphy.info writing persuasive essay writing persuasive essay [url=http://writing-persuasive-essay.knaphy.info ]writing persuasive essay[/url]
http://writing-business-plan.knaphy.info writing business plan[/url] ywriting business plan[/url] [url=http://writing-business-plan.knaphy.info ]writing business plan[/url]

Posted by: huli at February 22, 2007 02:49 AM


Posted by: money at February 27, 2007 12:48 AM

http://zappos-coupon.mvm1v.info zappos coupon [url=http://zappos-coupon.mvm1v.info]zappos coupon[/url]
http://drafting-table.wrw1r.info drafting table [url=http://drafting-table.wrw1r.info]drafting table[/url]
http://high-speed-internet.asa1s.info high speed internet [url=http://high-speed-internet.asa1s.info]high speed internet[/url]
http://venetian-blind.wrw1r.info venetian blind [url=http://venetian-blind.wrw1r.info]venetian blind[/url]

Posted by: Huisuki at March 1, 2007 04:48 AM

http://mobile-phone-games-download.eoe1o.info mobile phone games download [url=http://mobile-phone-games-download.eoe1o.info]mobile phone games download[/url]
http://high-speed-cable-internet.klpmm.com high speed cable internet [url=http://high-speed-cable-internet.klpmm.com]high speed cable internet[/url]
http://lcd-versus-plasma.eoe1o.info lcd versus plasma [url=http://lcd-versus-plasma.eoe1o.info]lcd versus plasma[/url]
http://teen-pregnancy-article.erw1r.info teen pregnancy article [url=http://teen-pregnancy-article.erw1r.info]teen pregnancy article[/url]
http://agent-estate-real-toronto.klpmm.com agent estate real toronto [url=http://agent-estate-real-toronto.klpmm.com]agent estate real toronto[/url]

Posted by: macsimsuka at March 6, 2007 05:26 AM


Posted by: gool at March 21, 2007 06:48 AM

HELP. Who than can on treatment 6 years children. It is necessary 75 000 $ dollars for complex operation. We ask you. Though as that help. Forward means for electronic purse WEBMONEY: WMID - 244643338994, Purse - Z379794871935. Parents of the boy.

Posted by: fankom at March 23, 2007 05:50 PM

http://dosug1.hut2.ru элитные девушки россии!

Posted by: boyut at July 6, 2007 02:16 AM

Самые дешевые и красивые проститутки РОССИИ http://dosug1.hut2.ru

Posted by: boyut at July 9, 2007 02:47 AM


Posted by: boyout at September 16, 2007 03:13 PM
Post a comment

Remember personal info?