Rick Hightower posted an interesting follow-up to Zed’s rant against Ruby on Rails. There are a lot of insightful comments in this discussion, and one in particular caught my attention:
People are tired of dealing with Java’s many idiosyncrasies
I’ve been reading this a lot these past years but I’ve yet to see any evidence of it.
Come to think of it, this statement is mostly coming from bloggers, but…
- They don’t speak for all Java developers (actually, they represent a very tiny fraction of them).
- They need to drive traffic to their blog, and nothing achieves this goal better than posts titled “Java is dying” or “Ruby has won”.
I’ve been programming in Java for more than ten years. I have studied a lot of languages, and I keep learning new ones just out of curiosity. I even use some of these exotic languages here and there as the need warrants. Yes, some of these feel really good to program in (Ruby and Groovy for example), but at the end of the day, I still like Java. A lot.
Sure, there are things in the language that bother me, but it’s true for any language, and as a whole, I always enjoy going back to my favorite Java IDE and leverage its superb features to write code that I find is elegant and that achieves a goal.
Whenever I use a non-Java language, I always have this nagging feeling in the back of my head that something is going to hold this piece of code from ever becoming mainstream or used by a lot of people. It can be because the language is slow, or that it needs an interpreter. Or that it will be hard to deploy my program on a user’s machine. Or that this language was created before OO became mainstream and its support for new paradigms feels retrofitted and creaky.
Or that its support for floating point is very poor. Or that its thread API is primitive and the author of the language keeps saying that it’s no big deal and that you can do without that. Or maybe it doesn’t have any Web framework that supports internationalization, a clean MVC model or out-of-the-box testing. Or I want to write a client application that leverages its host operating system but all that it offers is an ugly-looking user interface and leaking metaphors.
None of these defects take away the pleasure I derive from sometimes straying off the beaten path and writing code in an exotic language, but it does set my mind into a mode that tells me that this piece of code will never be promoted past the “toy” status.
Toy listings are great for sniped blog entries, but a mainstream programming language they do not make.
Whatever your favorite language is, be it Scala, Ruby, Python or Groovy, I’m with you. I really am. I understand the warm glow you feel when you write code in your language because I feel it too. But what you need to understand is that there is very little chance that your language will displace Java in any way in at least the next five years to come.
But please, keep posting cute code snippets that show how great your language is, because I love to be challenged in the way I think and indirectly, Java benefits from all these great ideas that keep being posted in the blogosphere.